Skip to main content

CASE SUMMARIES

Accommodation - CS112605

An undergraduate student complained about their provider's refusal to allow an Emotional Support Animal (ESA) to live with them in provider owned accommodation. The student felt the decision not to allow their cat to stay was procedurally unfair, did not consider all evidence provided and amounted to disability discrimination. The student wanted the provider to consider the cat as an auxiliary aid and noted that the provider did already allow other ESAs.

Accommodation - CS112601

A postgraduate student entered into a tenancy agreement for a room in provider-owned hall of residence. They collected the room keys the following day. When they went to see the room, they found visible damp, a bad smell and broken items which they recorded on the room’s inventory form. Shortly afterwards, the student asked to cancel their tenancy agreement and did not move in. The keys were handed back, and the student complained to the provider. They said the room did not match the standard and quality they had expected from the provider’s promotional material.

Free speech - CS082602

A student was withdrawn from their provider after they failed their final attempt at a core module. They complained to the provider that the marking of their work had departed from the published assessment criteria and had been influenced by the political views expressed in their work. The student said this was a violation of their freedom of speech and a breach of the Equality Act because it amounted to discrimination on the basis of religion or belief. 

Free speech - CS082601

A postgraduate student was conducting research on gender identity. The student did not pass their progress exam at the first attempt. The examiners had concerns about the student’s literature review and writing. They also raised an ethical concern about the research survey the student was using and said that the student should pause the survey and address their concerns.

Free speech - CS082604

A student complained to their provider about comments that had been made within a chat box by other students during an online teaching session. The session had explored historical arguments about the roles of women. The student said the comments were transphobic and discriminatory, and that the lecturer hadn’t taken proper steps to address them. The provider didn’t uphold the student’s complaint and the student complained to us. 

Free speech - CS082605

A provider received reports about a student’s conduct while living in its halls of residence, which said that the student had made comments that were queerphobic, transphobic and antisemitic, and that the student had made upsetting comments during a conversation about pregnancy and abortion rights. The provider considered the reports using its disciplinary procedures. 

Harassment and sexual misconduct - CS042608

A student (student A) made an online report about bullying and sexual harassment by another student (student B). Student A and student B were living in the same student flat. At student A’s request, the provider arranged for student A to move to alternative accommodation.

Academic appeals - CS042602

A student appealed their final award outcome on the basis that the supervision they received when undertaking their dissertation was inadequate.

Academic appeals - CS042604

A student enrolled to study on a Graduate Diploma in Law with a pre-sessional module attached. The student submitted their pre-sessional assessment after the standard deadline, but within the permitted late submission window. This resulted in the mark being capped at pass.

Academic appeals - CS042603

A final-year student was attempting a module for the second time. They were struggling to complete coursework for the module, so they applied for a one-week extension. The extension was given but the student’s work did not subsequently achieve a pass. The student had to complete an additional assessment before they received their final award. This meant that they would not be able to graduate immediately.

We publish summaries of some of the complaints that we review. We always leave out of the summary any information that might identify the student who made the complaint. In some cases we decide that it is in the public interest to publish a summary of a complaint that includes the name of the provider. 

Latest case summaries